The novel is starting to take shape nicely. I suppose you’d say I’ve completed a second draft. Still lots of issues to resolve, sections that could be tightened, flab to cut away. But overall, I’m pleased with the progress. (‘Pleased’ is the strongest adjective I use about my fiction; there will always be improvements to make, even after submission. Dissatisfaction, for me, is where motivation comes from.) A few more drafts, three weeks, say, and I’ll want someone to look at it.
I have two rules for showing work to others: Choose your reader(s) very carefully; and approach this phase with pragmatism.
Let’s look at the first. Say I ask a good friend, a non-writer who reads a lot, to have a look. They know I’ve been slaving away for over a year, they have a vested interest in maintaining our friendship (telling me it’s terrible might feel risky, and an utterly clean bill of health is of no use to me), and, well, their voracious reading habit doesn’t make them a good editor. Also, they might be excellent at spotting weaknesses, but have no idea how to resolve them. So, I now never give work to (close) friends; let them see it in its (I hope) published glory. This obviously goes for family members too, unless your aunt is a literary agent, your cousin a publisher. How about paying one of the many editorial services? Well, some out there are better than others, some will do more harm than good, so research is essential if taking this path. Ideally you want someone who is qualified to appraise every aspect of your manuscript, knows what you're trying to achieve, and who'll give you honest and valuable feedback. I’m lucky in having people I trust to do this.
Secondly, and I think this comes with experience, you need to receive this feedback as advice that will strengthen your book, not as a criticism of you the writer. If the person has done their job properly, there will be an awful lot of phrases, perhaps even whole scenes, a character maybe, that just don’t work. And hearing this can be devastating. There will be a few occasions when you remain faithful to your original output, but you need to remember you are too close to the work to regard it dispassionately, objectively. Now is the time to listen to Them What Know.
So there. A few more weeks and this epic journey I began 13 months ago will near its end. There’s just the small matter then of a publisher deciding it warrants a punt.
Happy secular holidays.